2014 - 2019 Youth Ministry
Investigation
Context
A third-party investigator, The Stier Group led by Amy Stier, was hired in January 2024 to explore the harm students and volunteers experienced in our youth ministry from 2014-2019. This situation was initially explored in 2021 through a pastoral inquiry. Those who experienced harm (the victims) asked for a more extensive investigation and The River’s board and senior leaders agreed that this action was necessary. In April 2026, Amy sent a letter to the Board stating that the investigation would not resume. See the update below with a link to the letter that explains her reasons in her own words.
Updates
April 17, 2026 Update
The River Board shared in this email communication that The Stier Group has independently ended its investigation into past misconduct and the church’s response, a decision the board did not influence. Acknowledging that not all questions will be answered, the board expresses ongoing grief over the harm experienced and a commitment to building a safer, more compassionate future.
March 7, 2026 Update
The criminal trial involving Brett Bymaster concluded in late November 2025, when a jury found him not guilty of 10 felony sexual abuse charges. Following the verdict, The River Board reached out to The Stier Group and is continuing to consult with them and legal experts as we prayerfully consider the best path forward.
July 25, 2024 Update from The Stier Group
Click here to read letterJanuary 25, 2024 Introduction from The Stier Group
Click here to read letterPlease direct questions to boardchair@the-river.org.
